Pellet Smoker Head to Head: Yoder YS640 vs Weber SmokeFire EX4
When it comes to pellet smokers, two models that frequently stand out are the Yoder YS640 and the Weber SmokeFire EX4. Both of these smokers are renowned for their unique features, durability, and performance, but they cater to different preferences and styles of outdoor cooking. In this blog, we’ll dive into a detailed comparison of these two popular pellet smokers, examining their features, performance, user experiences, and overall value.
TL;DR – Yoder YS640 vs. Weber SmokeFire EX4
-
Yoder YS640 is a heavy-duty, USA-made pellet smoker built for consistency and durability, ideal for serious backyard cooks and competitors.
-
Weber SmokeFire EX4 offers great versatility and high heat (up to 600°F), making it excellent for both grilling and smoking with a sleek, tech-forward design.
-
Yoder’s FireBoard-enabled controller and thick steel construction provide stable performance and long-term reliability.
-
Weber’s SmokeBoost mode enhances flavor early in the cook, but its smoke profile is generally milder than Yoder’s.
-
User feedback praises Yoder for build quality and consistent results; Weber gets credit for flexibility but requires regular maintenance.
-
Choose Yoder if you prioritize performance and longevity; go with Weber if you want a modern, do-it-all grill with strong app control.
Construction and Durability
Yoder YS640
The YS640 from Yoder Smokers is celebrated for its robust construction. Made in the USA, this smoker boasts heavy-duty 10 gauge steel for the hopper and 14 gauge steel for the cart. This solid build ensures long-term durability and reliability, though it does make the unit quite heavy at 335 lbs
The Yoder’s competition cart includes large 8” caster wheels, enhancing its mobility despite its weight.
Weber SmokeFire EX4
Source: weber.com
The Weber SmokeFire EX4 features a more modern design with a porcelain-enameled lid and stainless steel grates. While not as heavy-duty as the Yoder, it offers a sturdy build that’s easier to move around. This smoker is partially assembled in the USA, with some components sourced internationally
Temperature Control and Range
Yoder YS640
The Yoder YS640 is equipped with an advanced Adaptive Control System (ACS) that includes FireBoard technology for WiFi and Bluetooth connectivity. It offers a temperature range of 150°F to 600°F, providing flexibility for both low-and-slow smoking and high-heat grilling
The smoker's manual logic controller is designed to mimic traditional offset smokers, creating a temperature gradient that some users find advantageous for cooking different parts of meat at varying temperatures.
Weber SmokeFire EX4
The Weber SmokeFire EX4 uses the Weber Connect app for remote monitoring and control. Its temperature range is from 200°F to 600°F, allowing it to excel in both searing and smoking. However, the SmokeFire’s design can lead to uneven heat distribution and potential grease fires if not properly maintained
Cooking Space and Hopper Capacity
Yoder YS640
The Yoder YS640 offers a generous 1,070 square inches of cooking space, making it ideal for large gatherings and competitive cooking. It features a 20lb pellet hopper, which provides ample fuel for extended cooking sessions
Weber SmokeFire EX4
The Weber SmokeFire EX4 has 672 square inches of cooking space and a 22lb pellet hopper. The hopper includes a pellet release door for easy cleaning and switching of pellet types. Users may need to smooth out the pellets manually to ensure a continuous feed
Technology and Features
Yoder YS640
The integration of FireBoard technology in the Yoder YS640 allows for advanced remote monitoring and control. This smoker includes ports for multiple temperature probes and offers customizable cooking programs through the FireBoard app. However, it lacks some features found in other competitors’ apps, such as a built-in recipe database or a low pellet alarm
Weber SmokeFire EX4
The Weber SmokeFire EX4’s Connect app provides basic cooking programs and reminders. The design allows for versatile cooking methods, including searing, smoking, and grilling. Despite early mechanical issues, subsequent updates have improved its performance, making it a reliable option for many users
User Experience Feedback
Yoder YS640
Users praise the Yoder YS640 for its consistent performance and reliability. It maintains stable temperatures over long cooking sessions and produces a satisfactory smoke flavor, although some users enhance it with a pellet smoke tube. The build quality and customer support are highly regarded, contributing to a positive overall experience
Weber SmokeFire EX4
The Weber SmokeFire EX4 is favored for its versatility and high-heat capability. It produces a medium smoke flavor, which some users prefer. Despite initial release issues, ongoing improvements have led to better performance and user satisfaction. Regular maintenance is necessary to prevent grease buildup and ensure safety
The Verdict?
Both the Yoder YS640 and Weber SmokeFire EX4 are excellent pellet smokers, each with its unique strengths. The Yoder YS640 is ideal for those who value robust construction, advanced control features, and a large cooking area. It’s perfect for serious grill enthusiasts and competitive cooks. On the other hand, the Weber SmokeFire EX4 excels in versatility, ease of use, and modern technological features, making it a great choice for those seeking a multi-functional grill with high-heat capability.
Ultimately, the best choice depends on your specific needs and preferences. Whether you prioritize build quality and consistency or versatility and ease of use, both of these smokers offer exceptional performance that can elevate your outdoor cooking experience.